What started as a love for baking has become one of The Rustic Roost's most popular traditions.
Every pie is made with care by Macy, using quality ingredients and time-tested recipes that bring a homemade touch to every slice. From rich and creamy French Silk to classic Dutch Apple, Coconut Cream, Blueberry Crumble, Reese's Peanut Butter, and seasonal favorites, there's always something delicious coming out of the kitchen.
Our pies are baked fresh and available by the slice or as whole pies to share with family, friends, coworkers, or guests at your next gathering. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself, Macy's Pies are made to create sweet memories.
Popular flavors include:
French Silk
Coconut Cream
Dutch Apple
Blueberry Crumble
Cherry Crumble
Reese's Peanut Butter
Oreo Cream
Lemon Cream
Seasonal Specialty Pies
Whole pies are available for pre-order, and we recommend ordering ahead for holidays, special events, and favorite flavors.
To pre-order call The Rustic Roost 715-372-4426
Macy works hard to keep a selection of whole pies available during business hours, but availability may vary depending on demand and flavor selection.
Stop in and see why so many locals and travelers make Macy's Pies a must-have part of their visit to The Rustic Roost.